| 6.1.04: Countryside Alliance
Exaggerating - AGAIN! |
|
Anti-hunt group in attendance challenge
By Romee Latif, Birmingham Post
A leading anti-bloodsport group has accused the Countryside
Alliance of exaggerating the number of hunt supporters
who attended Boxing Day meets. Protect Our Wild
Animals (POWA) believe the group intentionally
inflated the figures in a bid to give a false impression
of the strength of support for hunting as Parliament prepares
to vote on the issue later this year.
The Countryside Alliance (CA) claimed
that as many as 275,000 people went out on Boxing Day
nationwide to support the annual hunt whereas POWA believe
the true figure was closer to 100,000. The anti-hunting
group came to the conclusion after scouring local press
reports on each of the hunts and comparing the attendance
figures reported in the newspapers with the figures released
by the Countryside Alliance.
According to POWA, the CA appeared to
have derived their national total 275,000 from a sample
of 36 meets whereas POWA used 46 "independent"
sources. Guesstimating that "hundreds" means
on average 350 and "several hundred" was around
650, the total for these 46 hunts is roughly 20,500, giving
an average of 446 per meet, according to POWA.
Examples highlighted by POWA include
claims by the CA that up to 1,750 hunt supporters followed
the hunt at Croome in Worcestershire whereas local media
reported just 600 in attendance. At the Worcestershire
hunt the CA claimed more than 1,500 turned up but newspapers
stated that hunters and protesters together numbered just
"hundreds".
Elsewhere POWA claim only a few hundred
turned out at Albrighton, 700 at Atherstone in Warwickshire
and 300 at the North Warwickshire hunt. The Countryside
Alliance also claimed there were 350 Boxing Day meets,
but their own Campaign for Hunting website states that
there are less than 300 fox, deer and hare hunts in England
and Wales.
Alan Kirby, spokesman for POWA, said:
"Hare hunts attract few supporters, even on Boxing
Day. The largest attested attendance at one we could find
was 300. Allowing for this, the fox hunts would have had
to average over 1,500 each. But we can find hardly any
independent reports of such crowds.
"The British Field Sports Society
was castigated by the Advertising Standards Authority
in 1993 for making wildly inflated claims about Boxing
Day attendances. The Alliance's claim is less grandiose,
but still seems wildly excessive."
The group also slammed a recent poll
conducted by the Countryside Alliance that claimed that
just two per cent of the public think that hunting should
be a priority for the Government. "What the poll
actually asked was what should be the Government's top
priority. Even we wouldn't reply 'banning hunting' to
that," said Mr Kirby. "But the latest scientific
poll shows at least 69 per cent want all hunting banned
and it will require only a little more parliamentary time
to effect that."
Full Story: Birmingham.icnetwork
|